Because not all advice is good advice, and not all mentors have your best interests at heart
What Mentorship Actually Is (And What It Isn’t)
Let’s start by clearing up some misconceptions. A mentor isn’t your fairy godparent who magically transforms your life with a wave of their networking wand. They’re also not your therapist, your parent, or someone who should be making decisions for you.
Good mentorship is more like having a GPS for your career and personal development – it helps you navigate, warns you about potential roadblocks, and suggests alternative routes when you hit traffic. But you’re still the one driving the car, choosing the destination, and deciding whether to take their suggested route.
The best mentoring relationships are partnerships where experience meets ambition, wisdom meets fresh perspective, and established networks meet hungry newcomers. When it works well, both people benefit and grow from the relationship.
The Game-Changing Benefits of Good Mentorship
Access to Networks You Couldn’t Reach Alone
A good mentor opens doors that you didn’t even know existed. They introduce you to people in their network, recommend you for opportunities, and give you access to conversations and circles that might take years to reach on your own.
Real-World Education
While you’re learning theories in school or online, mentors share what actually happens in the workplace. They tell you about office politics, industry trends, and the unwritten rules that no one puts in job descriptions, but everyone needs to know.
Confidence Building Through Validation
Having someone experienced believe in your potential and invest time in your growth is incredibly powerful. Good mentors help you see strengths you might not recognize in yourself and push you to take on challenges you might avoid.
Mistake Prevention
A mentor who’s been where you’re trying to go has already made the mistakes you’re about to make. They can help you avoid common pitfalls, saving you time, energy, and sometimes money.
Honest Feedback
Friends and family love you and want to support you, but they might not give you the brutal honesty you need to grow. Good mentors care enough about your success to tell you hard truths about your blind spots.
Long-Term Perspective
When you’re early in your career, it’s hard to see beyond the next job or promotion. Mentors help you think strategically about your long-term goals and how your current choices align with where you want to be in 5-10 years.
The Dark Side: When Mentorship Goes Wrong
I wanted to include this section because not all mentorship is created equal. Unfortunately, some mentoring relationships can harm your growth and well-being. I know this from personal experience. Here’s what to watch out for:
The Power Tripper
These mentors are more interested in feeling important than helping you succeed. They might withhold information to maintain power over you, take credit for your ideas, or make you feel like you owe them excessive gratitude for basic guidance.
The Cloner
Instead of helping you develop your unique strengths; these mentors try to turn you into a carbon copy of themselves. They push you toward their exact career path without considering your different interests, values, or circumstances.
The Boundary Violator
Mentorship should be professional and appropriate. Mentors who make you uncomfortable, ask inappropriate personal questions, or blur the lines between mentoring and something else are problematic.
The Gatekeeper
Some mentors become possessive and limit your growth by discouraging you from seeking other perspectives or opportunities they can’t provide. They might get jealous if you connect with other mentors or pursue paths they don’t approve of.
The Projector
These mentors project their own failures, fears, or biases onto you. They might discourage you from pursuing opportunities because they failed at something similar, or they might push their own unfulfilled dreams onto your career path.
The Credit Taker
These mentors, as the name implies, take credit for your work. This was the unfortunate experience I had with my first mentor. I would recommend copying yourself on your emails so that you can have a record of your work in case there is ever a question of who should be credited.
How to Identify a Great Mentor
They Ask Questions About Your Goals
Good mentors want to understand what you’re trying to achieve before offering advice. They ask about your values, interests, and long-term vision rather than immediately telling you what you should do.
They Share Both Successes and Failures
The best mentors are honest about their journey, including mistakes they’ve made, and lessons learned from failures. This vulnerability creates trust and provides you with realistic expectations.
They Connect You with Others
Great mentors don’t try to be your only source of guidance. They actively connect you with other people in their network who might help you, even if it means sharing their influence.
They Respect Your Time and Boundaries
Good mentors show up when they say they will, respect your schedule, and maintain appropriate boundaries. They don’t expect you to be available 24/7 or to prioritize their needs over your own.
They Challenge You Constructively
The best mentors push you outside your comfort zone while providing support and encouragement. They help you see what you’re capable of achieving, even when you doubt yourself.
They Celebrate Your Successes
A good mentor genuinely celebrates your wins without making it about themselves. They’re proud of your growth and achievements, not threatened by them.
What Good Mentoring Looks Like in Practice
Keep in mind that some people want to be mentors for a variety of reasons, but they may not know what good mentoring looks like. Here are some things to look for:
Regular, Structured Check-ins
Good mentoring relationships have some structure – regular meetings, clear agendas, and follow-up on previous conversations. It’s not just random advice over coffee when convenient.
Goal-Oriented Conversations
Sessions focus on your development goals, specific challenges you’re facing, and concrete steps you can take. Good mentors help you break down big goals into manageable actions.
Two-Way Learning
The best mentoring relationships involve mutual learning. Your mentor gains fresh perspectives from you while sharing their experience and wisdom.
Honest, Constructive Feedback
Good mentors tell you what you need to hear, not just what you want to hear. They deliver difficult feedback with kindness and specific suggestions for improvement.
Advocacy and Sponsorship
Beyond just giving advice, good mentors actively advocate for you. They recommend you for opportunities, speak positively about your work to others, and help advance your career.
Gradual Independence
Over time, good mentors help you become more independent and confident in your decision-making. The relationship evolves from heavy guidance to occasional check-ins and strategic advice.
Red Flags: When Mentorship Becomes Toxic
They Make Everything About Them
If your mentor constantly talks about their own achievements, uses your conversations to vent about their problems, or makes your successes about their great mentoring, that’s a red flag.
They Discourage Your Dreams
Mentors should help you pursue your goals, not convince you to abandon them. If someone consistently tells you your dreams are unrealistic without offering constructive alternatives, they’re not helping you grow.
They Create Dependency
Toxic mentors might deliberately keep you dependent on them by not teaching you to think critically or make decisions independently. They want you to need them rather than helping you become self-sufficient.
They Violate Confidentiality
What you share with your mentor should stay between you two unless you explicitly agree otherwise. Mentors who gossip about your personal information or professional struggles can’t be trusted.
They Have Hidden Agendas
Some people offer mentorship because they want something from you – free work, access to your network, or personal favors. True mentorship should benefit you, not primarily serve their needs.
They Don’t Respect Your Boundaries
Mentors who contact you constantly, expect immediate responses to non-urgent communications, or push you to do things that make you uncomfortable don’t respect appropriate boundaries.
How to Exit a Toxic Mentoring Relationship
Recognize That It’s Okay to Leave
First, give yourself permission to end the relationship. You don’t owe anyone unlimited access to your time and energy, even if they’ve helped you in the past.
Document Any Problematic Behavior
If the relationship is severely problematic, keep records of inappropriate communications or requests. This protects you if the situation escalates.
Have a Direct Conversation If Possible
Sometimes mentors don’t realize their behavior is problematic. If you feel safe doing so, have an honest conversation about your concerns and see if the relationship can be improved.
Create Distance Gradually
If direct confrontation isn’t safe or productive, gradually reduce contact. Respond less frequently, keep conversations brief and professional, and stop sharing personal information.
Seek Support
Talk to trusted friends, family members, or other professionals about the situation. They can provide perspective and emotional support as you navigate ending the relationship.
Don’t Burn Bridges Unnecessarily
Unless the mentor’s behavior was severely inappropriate, try to end the relationship professionally. You might encounter them again in your career, and maintaining basic professionalism serves you better than dramatic exits.
Finding Your Ideal Mentor
Look Beyond the Obvious Choices
Your ideal mentor might not be the most senior person in your field. Sometimes the best mentors are people just a few steps ahead of you who remember what it’s like to be where you are now.
Consider Peer Mentoring
Don’t overlook the value of peer mentors – people at similar career stages who are facing similar challenges. These relationships can be incredibly valuable and often more reciprocal.
Think About Different Types of Mentors
You might benefit from different mentors for different aspects of your life – career advancement, technical skills, work-life balance, or industry knowledge. No single person has to be your everything.
Look for Shared Values
Skills and experience matter, but shared values matter more for long-term mentoring relationships. Look for mentors whose approach to work and life aligns with your own principles.
Consider Reverse Mentoring
If you have skills or knowledge that someone more senior could benefit from (like technology, social media, or cultural insights), consider proposing a reverse mentoring relationship where you both learn from each other.
How to Be a Great Mentee
Come Prepared
Don’t waste your mentor’s time by showing up without clear questions or goals. Prepare specific topics you want to discuss and challenges you’re facing. As you move higher in your career, you want to always bring an agenda. What I mean by that is that you should always have clear questions and goals. It will impress whoever you’re meeting with. It shows that you understand their time is valuable.
Follow Through
If your mentor suggests actions or resources, follow through and report back. This shows respect for their advice and helps them understand what’s working for you.
Be Honest About Your Struggles
Don’t try to impress your mentor by pretending everything is perfect. They can help you more effectively if you’re honest about challenges and mistakes. But be careful not to become known as a complainer or negative personality.
Respect Their Time
Show up on time, stick to agreed-upon meeting lengths, and don’t expect immediate responses to non-urgent communications. Your mentor is doing you a favor, not fulfilling a job requirement.
Express Gratitude
Regularly thank your mentor for their time and guidance. Let them know specifically how their advice has helped you and update them on your progress.
Give Back When You Can
Look for ways to add value to the relationship. This might be sharing industry insights, making introductions, or simply being an engaged and appreciative mentee.
Building a Mentorship Network
Multiple Mentors for Different Needs
Instead of looking for one perfect mentor, build a network of people who can guide you in different areas. You might have a career mentor, a technical mentor, and a life balance mentor. But be careful not to go overboard.
Formal vs. Informal Mentoring
Some of your best mentoring relationships might be informal – regular conversations with people you admire rather than officially structured mentoring programs.
Online Mentoring Opportunities
Virtual mentoring has opened possibilities for connecting with mentors regardless of geographic location. Many successful professionals are willing to mentor virtually.
The Long Game: Becoming a Mentor Yourself
Pay It Forward
One of the best parts of receiving good mentorship is eventually being able to mentor others. This creates a positive cycle that benefits entire communities and industries.
Start Small
You don’t need to be at the top of your field to mentor someone. As soon as you have knowledge or experience that could help someone a step behind you, you can be a mentor.
Learn from Being a Mentor
Mentoring others often teaches you as much as being mentored. It helps you articulate your own knowledge, see your field from fresh perspectives, and develop leadership skills.
When Mentorship Isn’t Enough
Recognize the Limits
Mentorship is powerful, but it’s not a cure-all. Some challenges require therapy, coaching, or other forms of professional support rather than traditional mentoring.
Systemic Issues Need Systemic Solutions
While mentors can help you navigate systemic barriers, they can’t single-handedly eliminate discrimination, bias, or structural inequalities. Don’t blame yourself or your mentor if individual guidance can’t overcome systemic problems.
Professional Development Resources
Supplement mentorship with formal training, education, and professional development opportunities. Mentors provide guidance, but you still need to develop skills and knowledge through other channels.
Your Mentorship Journey
Finding good mentorship is like dating – it takes time, effort, and sometimes a few disappointing experiences before you find the right fit. Don’t get discouraged if your first mentoring relationship doesn’t work out perfectly, and don’t settle for mentors who don’t truly support your growth.
Remember that the goal of mentorship is to help you become the best version of yourself, not to turn you into someone else. Good mentors guide you toward your own goals and values, not theirs.
Trust Your Instincts
If something feels off in a mentoring relationship, trust that feeling. You deserve mentors who respect you, support your goals, and maintain appropriate boundaries.
Be Patient with the Process
Building meaningful mentoring relationships takes time. Don’t expect instant results or perfect matches. The best mentoring relationships often develop gradually over months or years.
Stay Open to Learning
The most successful mentees are curious, coachable, and open to feedback. Approach mentorship with humility and a genuine desire to learn and grow.
The right mentors can accelerate your growth, expand your opportunities, and help you navigate challenges with confidence. They can’t do the work for you, but they can help you work smarter, avoid common pitfalls, and see possibilities you might have missed.
Your career and personal development are too important to navigate alone, but they’re also too important to entrust to just anyone. Choose your mentors wisely, invest in those relationships, and remember that the ultimate goal is to become confident and capable enough to eventually mentor others.
The higher you want to rise, the more important it becomes to have experienced guides who can help you navigate the journey. Find mentors who believe in your potential, respect your values, and genuinely want to see you succeed – then pay it forward by becoming that mentor for someone else.
Ready to find your mentor? Start by identifying what specific guidance you need most, then look for people whose experience and values align with your goals. And remember – you deserve mentors who genuinely want to see you succeed.
0 Comments